MessyPig

Original research

Which kitchenware brands actually publish what’s in their products

We read the documentation for 136 products across five categories. Only 1 publishes a named laboratory and a report you can open, and 17 sell a coating whose chemistry they never name.

We read every page, FAQ, care instruction, warranty and statutory filing we could find for 136 products across cookware, lunchboxes, food storage, bottles and air fryers. Not to work out which is safest — we have no laboratory and could not tell you that. To work out something simpler and, it turns out, more useful: which manufacturers will actually put their materials in writing.

The answer is that most will not, and the ones making the loudest safety claims are frequently the ones publishing the least.

How to read the table below

The total is our materials score: 60 points for what the food actually touches, 25 for the lids, seals and handles, 15 for whether anyone other than the manufacturer has confirmed it. The full rubric is published here.

This page is about that last column, and about the first: you cannot score a material well if nobody will name it. A low score does not mean a product is unsafe. It means the food meets a coating or a plastic — or that nobody will say what it meets.

The findings

1. Only 1 of 136 publish a named laboratory and an actual report

Xtrema Classic Skillet. That is it.

Xtrema publishes dated SGS certificates for California Prop 65 lead and cadmium leaching going back years. Caraway runs a public testing hub, names Light Labs, and links a report covering over 200 PFAS compounds and 20+ heavy metals.

Everyone else either references testing without naming who did it, or publishes nothing at all.

2. 83 of 136 publish nothing at all beyond their own description

Not a lab, not a certificate, not a standard, not even a statutory filing: Our Place Always Pan (ceramic), ECOlunchbox Three-in-One Giant, Bentgo Kids Stainless Steel, Onyx Airtight Container 18cm, Pyrex Simply Store, Hydro Flask Kids 12 oz Bottle, Fritaire Glass Air Fryer 5qt, Typhur Dome 2, Cosori Iconic Stainless Steel 6.5qt, Our Place Wonder Oven, Ello Syndicate 20 oz Glass, Takeya Actives 18 oz, Iron Flask 40 oz Wide Mouth, CamelBak Eddy+ Kids 14 oz, U-Konserve Rectangle Container 25 oz, WECK Mold Jar, IKEA 365+ Glass Container 34 oz, Glasslock Oven Safe 18pc Set, Ball Mason Jars, Wide Mouth 12-pack, Rubbermaid Brilliance Glass 10pc Set, reCAP POUR Mason Jar Lid, Rubbermaid Brilliance 10-Piece Set, OXO Good Grips POP Container 2.8 qt, Elephant Box 2L Stainless, LunchBots Small Snack Packer, OmieBox Hot & Cold Bento, kinsho Mini Steel Bento, 3-compartment, WeeSprout Stainless Bento, Large, Hydro Flask 12 oz Kids Food Jar, Thermos FUNtainer 10 oz Food Jar, Bentgo Kids Lunch Box (plastic), PackIt Freezable Lunch Box, Simple Modern Porter Bento Box, Demeyere Atlantis Proline 9" Fry Pan, de Buyer MINERAL B 10.25" Fry Pan, Misen 5-Ply Stainless Skillet 12", Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel 10.25", Le Creuset Signature Skillet, Staub 7 qt Round Cocotte, HexClad 12" Hybrid Frying Pan, Cuisinart ClearView 4 qt Glass Basket, Ninja Air Fryer Max XL 5.5 qt, Ninja Crispi Portable Glass Air Fryer, Hamilton Beach 5.8 qt Digital Air Fryer, Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer BOV860, Lifefactory 22 oz Glass Bottle, MiiR Wide Mouth Bottle, Hydro Flask 32 oz Wide Mouth, Black+Blum Stainless Lunch Box Large, Klean Kanteen 34 oz Rise Food Box, Mepal Campus Bento Lunchbox, Klean Kanteen 16 oz TKCanister, Libbey Baker’s Basics Glass Bowl Set, Bormioli Rocco Frigoverre 4.7-Cup, Set of 8, Ello Duraglass 5 Cup Container, Duralex Freshbox Square Set, Gourmia 7 qt Glass Basket Air Fryer, Dreo ChefMaker Combi Fryer 6 qt, Kirkland Signature 12-Piece Non-Stick Cookware Set, Le Creuset 9-Piece Stainless Steel Set (Costco), Beautiful 12-Piece EverGood Ceramic Cookware Set, Thyme & Table Signature 12-Piece Cookware Set, Thyme & Table Granite 12-Piece Cookware Set, Beautiful 12-Piece Ceramic Set, Black Sesame, Circulon Premier Professional 13-Piece (Costco), Thyme & Table Supreme 12-Piece Cookware Set, The Pioneer Woman Prairie Signature Fry Pan 8in, Mainstays 13-Piece Nonstick Aluminium Cookware Set, Mainstays 7-Piece Nonstick Aluminium Cookware Set, Thyme & Table Hard Anodized 15-Piece Set, Beautiful 6 Qt Air Fryer, EverGood Ceramic (Lavender), Beautiful 6 Qt Air Fryer, TurboCrisp (Sage Green), Beautiful 6 Qt Air Fryer, TurboCrisp (Black Sesame), Ninja Crispi 5-in-1 Glass Air Fry System (Costco), Ninja Foodi 6-in-1 10-qt DualZone Air Fryer (Costco), Snapware Pyrex 18-Piece Glass Storage Set (Costco), Mainstays Food Storage Bento Container 42oz, Mainstays Kids 4-Compartment Bento Box, Ozark Trail 40oz Insulated Stainless Bottle, Ozark Trail 32oz Insulated Flip-Straw Bottle, Ozark Trail 1.1-Liter Insulated Stainless Bottle, Owala SmoothSip Slider 20oz 2-Pack (Costco), Contigo Autoseal Couture 20oz 2-Pack (Costco).

The lowest total on the list is Our Place, whose Always Pan carries the strongest “free of” language we found anywhere. They do file a California AB 1200 disclosure, which is one point more than nothing — but it itemises the metals in the aluminium body and says nothing about the coating, which is the only part anyone is asking about. Its coating is called Thermakind, which is a trade name, not a material.

The brand with the most confident non-toxic marketing in our set publishes the least evidence of anything in it.

3. 17 of 136 have a coating and will not name its chemistry

Our Place Always Pan (ceramic), Our Place Wonder Oven, PackIt Freezable Lunch Box, Kalorik MAXX Advance 26 qt, Chefman TurboFry Touch “Stainless-Steel” 8 qt, Instant Vortex 9 qt VersaZone, Hamilton Beach 5.8 qt Digital Air Fryer, Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer BOV860, Thyme & Table Supreme 12-Piece Cookware Set, The Pioneer Woman Prairie Signature Fry Pan 8in, Mainstays 13-Piece Nonstick Aluminium Cookware Set, Mainstays 7-Piece Nonstick Aluminium Cookware Set, Thyme & Table Hard Anodized 15-Piece Set, Beautiful 6 Qt Air Fryer, TurboCrisp (Sage Green), Beautiful 6 Qt Air Fryer, TurboCrisp (Black Sesame), Ninja Crispi 5-in-1 Glass Air Fry System (Costco), Ninja Foodi 6-in-1 10-qt DualZone Air Fryer (Costco). A trade name is not a material, and this is the one gap that cannot be worked around: for every other product on the table you can at least reason about the stuff it is made of.

4. 81 of 136 will not name a country of manufacture

This is the single easiest fact in the world to publish, and it is the one most often missing. Caraway offers “mindfully manufactured in BSCI-certified factories”, which is not a country. Hydro Flask, Bentgo, LunchBots and Our Place simply do not say.

Country of manufacture does not enter the materials score at all — a steel grade is a steel grade wherever it is rolled. We report it because readers ask, and because a brand that will not name a country is usually not naming other things either.

5. Paying more gets you worse materials

A $24.90 Lodge cast iron skillet outscores a $125 Caraway pan by 25 points. A $9.95 Klean Kanteen bottle outscores a $22.49 Hydro Flask by 22. The most expensive single item on the table is a $349.95 oven that scores 17, because its maker publishes no food-contact material at all. Across the priced products the correlation between price and materials is negative. The current figure, recomputed on every build, is here.

The reason is structural rather than cynical. Money in this category buys coatings, non-stick performance and electronics, and every one of those puts something between the food and an inert surface. The full numbers are here.

Every product, scored

ProductTotalTouches foodThe restBackedBacked by what
Pura Sport Mini 11 ozBottles96/10060/6025/2511/15Statutory filing
Xtrema Classic SkilletCookware96/10060/6021/2515/15Publishes a report
Heritage Steel Titanium 12" Fry PanCookware92/10060/6021/2511/15Statutory filing
Made In Stainless Clad Frying PanCookware92/10060/6021/2511/15Statutory filing
PlanetBox LaunchLunchboxes87/10060/6021/256/15Asserts conformity
PlanetBox RoverLunchboxes87/10060/6021/256/15Asserts conformity
Elephant Box 2L StainlessLunchboxes85/10060/6025/250/15Nothing published
LunchBots Small Snack PackerLunchboxes85/10060/6025/250/15Nothing published
Anchor Hocking TrueSealFood storage84/10060/6013/2511/15Statutory filing
YETI Rambler 26 oz Straw BottleBottles84/10060/6013/2511/15Statutory filing
Klean Kanteen Kids Classic 12ozBottles83/10060/6017/256/15Asserts conformity
Le Parfait Super JarFood storage83/10060/6017/256/15Asserts conformity
Smithey Ironware No. 12 SkilletCookware83/10047/6025/2511/15Statutory filing
Thermos FUNtainer 12 oz BottleBottles83/10060/6017/256/15Asserts conformity
Tramontina Tri-Ply Clad 12" Fry PanCookware83/10060/6017/256/15Asserts conformity
bkr Little Bottle 500 mlBottles83/10060/6017/256/15Asserts conformity
Black+Blum Stainless Lunch Box LargeLunchboxes81/10060/6021/250/15Nothing published
Fritaire Glass Air Fryer 5qtAir fryers81/10060/6021/250/15Nothing published
Lifefactory 22 oz Glass BottleBottles81/10060/6021/250/15Nothing published
U-Konserve Rectangle Container 25 ozFood storage81/10060/6021/250/15Nothing published
LunchBots Large CincoLunchboxes79/10060/6013/256/15Asserts conformity
ECOlunchbox Three-in-One GiantLunchboxes78/10053/6025/250/15Nothing published
Lodge Classic Cast Iron SkilletCookware78/10042/6025/2511/15Statutory filing
Bentgo Kids Stainless SteelLunchboxes77/10060/6017/250/15Nothing published
Demeyere Atlantis Proline 9" Fry PanCookware77/10060/6017/250/15Nothing published
Klean Kanteen 16 oz TKCanisterFood storage77/10060/6017/250/15Nothing published
MiiR Wide Mouth BottleBottles77/10060/6017/250/15Nothing published
OmieBox Hot & Cold BentoLunchboxes77/10060/6017/250/15Nothing published
Onyx Airtight Container 18cmFood storage77/10060/6017/250/15Nothing published
de Buyer MINERAL B 10.25" Fry PanCookware77/10060/6017/250/15Nothing published
kinsho Mini Steel Bento, 3-compartmentLunchboxes77/10060/6017/250/15Nothing published
All-Clad D3 Stainless Fry PanCookware76/10053/6017/256/15Asserts conformity
Merten & Storck Carbon Steel 12" FrypanCookware76/10053/6017/256/15Asserts conformity
Stanley Quencher H2.0 FlowState 40 ozBottles74/10060/608/256/15Asserts conformity
Klean Kanteen 34 oz Rise Food BoxLunchboxes73/10060/6013/250/15Nothing published
Libbey Baker’s Basics Glass Bowl SetFood storage73/10060/6013/250/15Nothing published
Owala FreeSip 24 ozBottles72/10053/6013/256/15Asserts conformity
Simple Modern Summit 32 ozBottles72/10053/6013/256/15Asserts conformity
Stasher Gallon BagFood storage71/10040/6025/256/15Asserts conformity
Stasher Reusable Sandwich BagLunchboxes71/10040/6025/256/15Asserts conformity
Bormioli Rocco Frigoverre 4.7-Cup, Set of 8Food storage70/10053/6017/250/15Nothing published
Glasslock Oven Safe 18pc SetFood storage70/10053/6017/250/15Nothing published
IKEA 365+ Glass Container 34 ozFood storage70/10053/6017/250/15Nothing published
Misen 5-Ply Stainless Skillet 12"Cookware70/10053/6017/250/15Nothing published
Snapware Total Solution Pyrex 10pcFood storage70/10047/6017/256/15Asserts conformity
WECK Mold JarFood storage70/10053/6017/250/15Nothing published
Hydro Flask 12 oz Kids Food JarLunchboxes68/10060/608/250/15Nothing published
Ozark Trail 32oz Insulated Flip-Straw BottleBottles68/10060/608/250/15Nothing published
Ozark Trail 40oz Insulated Stainless BottleBottles68/10060/608/250/15Nothing published
WeeSprout Stainless Bento, LargeLunchboxes68/10060/608/250/15Nothing published
Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel 10.25"Cookware67/10042/6025/250/15Nothing published
Purist Mover 18 ozBottles67/10053/608/256/15Asserts conformity
Souper Cubes Complete 29-Piece SetFood storage67/10040/6021/256/15Asserts conformity
Ball Mason Jars, Wide Mouth 12-packFood storage66/10053/6013/250/15Nothing published
Brita Premium Filtering Bottle 32 ozBottles66/10047/608/2511/15Statutory filing
Ello Duraglass 5 Cup ContainerFood storage66/10053/6013/250/15Nothing published
Le Creuset 9-Piece Stainless Steel Set (Costco)Cookware66/10053/6013/250/15Nothing published
Cuisinart ClearView 4 qt Glass BasketAir fryers64/10047/6017/250/15Nothing published
FINEX 12" Cast Iron SkilletCookware62/10047/604/2511/15Statutory filing
Contigo Autoseal Couture 20oz 2-Pack (Costco)Bottles61/10053/608/250/15Nothing published
Duralex Freshbox Square SetFood storage61/10053/608/250/15Nothing published
Ello Syndicate 20 oz GlassBottles61/10053/608/250/15Nothing published
Hydro Flask Kids 12 oz BottleBottles61/10053/608/250/15Nothing published
Owala SmoothSip Slider 20oz 2-Pack (Costco)Bottles61/10053/608/250/15Nothing published
Ozark Trail 1.1-Liter Insulated Stainless BottleBottles61/10053/608/250/15Nothing published
Rubbermaid Brilliance Glass 10pc SetFood storage61/10053/608/250/15Nothing published
Snapware Pyrex 18-Piece Glass Storage Set (Costco)Food storage61/10053/608/250/15Nothing published
Thermos FUNtainer 10 oz Food JarLunchboxes61/10053/608/250/15Nothing published
GreenPan Valencia Pro FrypanCookware57/10034/6017/256/15Asserts conformity
Le Creuset Signature SkilletCookware55/10034/6021/250/15Nothing published
Pyrex Simply StoreFood storage55/10047/608/250/15Nothing published
Staub 7 qt Round CocotteCookware55/10034/6021/250/15Nothing published
Nuwave Brio Plus 7 qtAir fryers54/10026/6017/2511/15Statutory filing
Blue Diamond Classic 12" FrypanCookware53/10034/6013/256/15Asserts conformity
Caraway Ceramic Fry PanCookware53/10034/6013/256/15Asserts conformity
Hydro Flask 32 oz Wide MouthBottles53/10053/600/250/15Nothing published
Iron Flask 40 oz Wide MouthBottles53/10053/600/250/15Nothing published
Takeya Actives 18 ozBottles53/10053/600/250/15Nothing published
Caraway 12-pc Food Storage SetFood storage50/10026/6013/2511/15Statutory filing
Chefman TurboFry Dual Basket 9 qtAir fryers50/10026/6013/2511/15Statutory filing
Beautiful 12-Piece EverGood Ceramic Cookware SetCookware47/10034/6013/250/15Nothing published
Cosori Iconic Stainless Steel 6.5qtAir fryers47/10026/6021/250/15Nothing published
Ninja Air Fryer Max XL 5.5 qtAir fryers47/10034/6013/250/15Nothing published
Thyme & Table Signature 12-Piece Cookware SetCookware47/10034/6013/250/15Nothing published
Calphalon Premier Nonstick 12"Cookware43/10019/6013/2511/15Statutory filing
HexClad 12" Hybrid Frying PanCookware43/10026/6017/250/15Nothing published
Ninja Crispi Portable Glass Air FryerAir fryers43/10026/6017/250/15Nothing published
reCAP POUR Mason Jar LidFood storage43/10022/6021/250/15Nothing published
All-Clad HA1 Nonstick 12"Cookware42/10014/6017/2511/15Statutory filing
SCANPAN CLASSIC 10.25" Fry PanCookware42/10014/6017/2511/15Statutory filing
Bentgo Kids Lunch Box (plastic)Lunchboxes39/10022/6017/250/15Nothing published
CamelBak Eddy+ Kids 14 ozBottles39/10022/6017/250/15Nothing published
Kirkland Signature 12-Piece Non-Stick Cookware SetCookware39/10014/6025/250/15Nothing published
Elite Gourmet 23L Digital Air Fryer OvenAir fryers38/10014/6013/2511/15Statutory filing
Philips Airfryer HD9650 seriesAir fryers38/10014/6013/2511/15Statutory filing
T-fal Infrared Air Fryer 7.3 qtAir fryers38/10014/6013/2511/15Statutory filing
T-fal Ultimate Hard Anodized 2-pc SetCookware38/10014/6013/2511/15Statutory filing
Nalgene 32 oz Wide Mouth SustainBottles36/10022/608/256/15Asserts conformity
monbento MB Tresor Kids BentoLunchboxes36/10022/608/256/15Asserts conformity
Mepal Campus Bento LunchboxLunchboxes35/10022/6013/250/15Nothing published
Rubbermaid Brilliance 10-Piece SetFood storage35/10022/6013/250/15Nothing published
Yumbox Original Leakproof BentoLunchboxes35/10016/6013/256/15Asserts conformity
Beautiful 12-Piece Ceramic Set, Black SesameCookware34/10034/600/250/15Nothing published
Beautiful 6 Qt Air Fryer, EverGood Ceramic (Lavender)Air fryers34/10034/600/250/15Nothing published
Thyme & Table Granite 12-Piece Cookware SetCookware34/10034/600/250/15Nothing published
De’Longhi IdealFry Rapid Crisp 4 qtAir fryers33/10014/608/2511/15Statutory filing
Instant Vortex Plus 6qtAir fryers33/10014/6013/256/15Asserts conformity
Mainstays Food Storage Bento Container 42ozFood storage33/10016/6017/250/15Nothing published
Zojirushi 35 oz Stainless BottleBottles33/10014/6013/256/15Asserts conformity
Dreo ChefMaker Combi Fryer 6 qtAir fryers32/10019/6013/250/15Nothing published
Gourmia 7 qt Glass Basket Air FryerAir fryers32/10019/6013/250/15Nothing published
Typhur Dome 2Air fryers32/10019/6013/250/15Nothing published
Circulon Premier Professional 13-Piece (Costco)Cookware31/10014/6017/250/15Nothing published
Contigo Kids Straw Bottle 14 ozBottles30/10016/608/256/15Asserts conformity
Kalorik MAXX Advance 26 qtAir fryers28/1000/6017/2511/15Statutory filing
Chefman TurboFry Touch “Stainless-Steel” 8 qtAir fryers27/1008/6013/256/15Asserts conformity
Instant Vortex 9 qt VersaZoneAir fryers27/1008/6013/256/15Asserts conformity
Circulon A1 ScratchDefense 12-Piece (Costco)Cookware25/10014/600/2511/15Statutory filing
Circulon Premier Professional 10-Piece (Costco)Cookware25/10014/600/2511/15Statutory filing
Thyme & Table Supreme 12-Piece Cookware SetCookware25/1008/6017/250/15Nothing published
Mainstays Kids 4-Compartment Bento BoxLunchboxes24/10016/608/250/15Nothing published
Hamilton Beach 5.8 qt Digital Air FryerAir fryers21/1008/6013/250/15Nothing published
Our Place Always Pan (ceramic)Cookware21/1008/6013/250/15Nothing published
Our Place Wonder OvenAir fryers21/1008/6013/250/15Nothing published
PackIt Freezable Lunch BoxLunchboxes21/1008/6013/250/15Nothing published
The Pioneer Woman Prairie Signature Fry Pan 8inCookware21/1008/6013/250/15Nothing published
Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer BOV860Air fryers17/1000/6017/250/15Nothing published
Ninja Crispi 5-in-1 Glass Air Fry System (Costco)Air fryers16/1008/608/250/15Nothing published
OXO Good Grips POP Container 2.8 qtFood storage16/10016/600/250/15Nothing published
Simple Modern Porter Bento BoxLunchboxes16/10016/600/250/15Nothing published
Beautiful 6 Qt Air Fryer, TurboCrisp (Sage Green)Air fryers8/1008/600/250/15Nothing published
Mainstays 13-Piece Nonstick Aluminium Cookware SetCookware8/1008/600/250/15Nothing published
Mainstays 7-Piece Nonstick Aluminium Cookware SetCookware8/1008/600/250/15Nothing published
Ninja Foodi 6-in-1 10-qt DualZone Air Fryer (Costco)Air fryers8/1008/600/250/15Nothing published
Thyme & Table Hard Anodized 15-Piece SetCookware8/1008/600/250/15Nothing published
Beautiful 6 Qt Air Fryer, TurboCrisp (Black Sesame)Air fryers0/1000/600/250/15Nothing published

Every underlying claim, with its source link, is on the full table. Prices and pages read 1 September 2026.

The pattern worth naming

There is an inverse relationship in this data, and it is uncomfortable enough to state plainly: across our set, the strength of a brand’s non-toxic marketing runs opposite to both the simplicity of its materials and the strength of its published evidence.

The products at the top of the table are mostly ones that make small, boring, checkable claims — a named steel grade, a published oxide formula, a dated lab certificate, a country. The products at the bottom are mostly ones that make large, warm, unfalsifiable ones.

That is not proof that anything is unsafe. It is proof that the market currently rewards saying “non-toxic” more than it rewards proving it — because until someone checks, saying it is free and proving it costs money.

What would change these scores

Very little, and that is the point. Every one of these is a document a brand could publish tomorrow:

  • Name the material. Not Thermakind or Thermolon — the actual composition class.
  • Name the laboratory and publish the report. “Third-party tested” with no lab and no document is a sentence, not evidence.
  • State the country. One line.
  • Match the claim to the evidence. If what you can substantiate is “no intentionally added PFAS”, say that, and not “PFAS-free”. They are different promises, and in California and Colorado the difference is now regulated.
We have asked them

We have put the specific gap in each of these records to the brand concerned — what Thermakind is made of, which glass Pyrex uses, whether ECOlunchbox ships 201 or 304 steel, which claim GreenPan stands behind.

We will publish what they send, and we will publish the silences. If a brand answers, its score goes up that week and we will say so. This page is where the answers will appear.

Method, and its limits

  • We do not lab-test. No laboratory, no kitchen trials. Everything above is document research, and every underlying claim is linked on the full table.
  • Absence of published evidence is not evidence of harm. We have tried to write this page so that it cannot be quoted as saying any product is dangerous, because our data does not support that and never could.
  • 136 products is a small sample, weighted towards what people actually buy in these four categories. We are extending it, and the scores will move as brands respond.
  • We are in no affiliate programme. No link on this site is paid, and the top-scoring product here is one we have no way to earn from.

Related

Sources

  1. MessyPig materials rubric. How we score
  2. Full sourced product table, all 136 products. What we’ve checked
  3. Caraway third-party testing hub. carawayhome.com
  4. Xtrema product testing certificates (SGS). xtrema.com
  5. Our Place non-stick Always Pan page. fromourplace.com
  6. Pyrex FAQ — discusses both glass types without stating which is used. pyrexhome.com
  7. PlanetBox FAQ — steel grades, testing, country of manufacture. planetbox.com
  8. ECOlunchbox FAQ — the “201 or 304” disclosure. ecolunchboxes.com
  9. California Attorney General, AB 1200 Enforcement Advisory. oag.ca.gov
  10. Colorado Revised Statutes §25-15-604. law.justia.com

Related pages

One useful email a fortnight

New scores, brands that finally answered, and any rule change that affects what you can buy. The list is not open yet — email us and we will add you when it is.